Tysonjackson - Shana is A.D.

Shana is A.D. is a fanon idea I came up with the other day that explores the idea of Shana having survived her "death" and actually been on the A-Team. The more I fleshed my story out, the more I loved it so I decided to share it with everyone here!

Plot
In this version, the mystery plays out almost the same except for "A.D.'s" identity is changed. There are a few plot points not worked out but here is the basic story: Shana is revealed to be "A.D." and goes on to explain her story. As it turns out, Shana's character had a deeper purpose: She was Maya's half-twin sister. Same mother, different fathers. Shana lived with her Grandmother in Georgia, while Maya got to live with her mother and father. Shana and Maya had been in touch, however, Shana became worried when Maya went missing in Season 2. She came to Rosewood to find Shana and enlisted Jenna's help, as Jenna and Maya were friends. When Jenna met Shana in the park in 2x25 and gave her instructions, she was actually helping her meet Maya. Maya had communicated with Jenna and offered to meet Shana in secret at the Masquerade Ball. Lucas and Melissa were helping as well and the person Jenna was texting was Maya. Maya never showed up and then they found her dead, prompting Shana to realize it was the killer texting them. Shana decided to find Maya's killer and used "A" as a cover, stealing the idea from Mona. Unbeknownst to her, Charlotte had also started an "A" game and was running around as Red Coat. Shana had Jenna, Melissa, and Wilden working on her team and she was the one who sent them on the train, not Charlotte. Shana and Charlotte discovered each other and decided to join forces, but Charlotte became angry with Shana when she set the fire, prompting them to break off their friendship. After Nigel spilled her name, Charlotte tried to kill Jenna and this is what led Shana to reveal CeCe's name, out of anger. Eventually Charlotte and Shana joined forces again after New York and worked together in the Dollhouse. However, Shana and her team (Noel and Jenna) decided to let Charlotte and Sara have the game and end it. Shana left town and the game ended, until Charlotte was murdered and Shana decided to come back as "A.D.". The reason she asked Aria to join the A-Team was to personally torture her and make her turn against her friends due to Aria "killing" her. Hope you all enjoyed the parts I've worked out so far! :)

Also in my version, Sara Harvey is the girl from the Frat Party that Noel pushed. She went there with a fake name, wig, and identity similar to Vivian Darkbloom. Charlotte found her and told her that Alison and the Liars were responsible, which is why she joined the A-Team.